Billy Night 2 was everything Night 1 was not. It was polite, controlled, respectful, and safe.
The reckless abandon that made N1 one of the best Phish sit-ins ever was nowhere to be found—as if Trey had Billy on a tight leash after giving him the keys to the car and letting him run wild the previous night.
Even Flatpick Jesus can’t save a show unless you give him a little something more to work with.